How the Oracle judges
Every thesis sent to the judge is examined twice, on the server, so no browser can fake a pass. A fixed rubric checks what can be checked exactly. Then the Oracle, a strong language model, reads it like a demanding professor and asks whether the paradox is truly resolved.
IThe rubric
Exact checks, the same code in your browser and on the server.
- 35Answers
- 30Concepts
- 15Structure
- 10Objections
- 10Length
IIThe Oracle
A model's review: Claude, GPT, Gemini, OpenRouter, Grok or DeepSeek.
- 35Resolution
- 25Rigor
- 15Objections
- 15Clarity
- 10Originality
The final score is the average of the two. A thesis passes at 70 with every answer right, at least 300 words, and an Oracle score of 60 or more with the verdict sound. Keyword stuffing and restating the paradox without resolving it are scored down hard; instructions aimed at the grader fail outright. Laurels: gold from 90, silver from 80, bronze from 70.